It sent shockwaves through the villa when they broke up earlier in the season over blonde bombshell Chloe.
Fashion blogger Kaz, 26, is confronted by the semi-professional footballer, 22, who demands an answer to why she chose to ‘pie’ him out of all the boys.
Awkward: Toby and Kaz (pictured), become engaged in a heated debate on Tuesday’s episode of Love Island in the aftermath of the Snog Marry Pie challenge
During a conversation about why they ended their brief romance, Toby changes his tune from saying he ‘had no regrets’ about ditching her for Chloe, 25, before backtracking and saying he ‘understood her point of view’ – enraging Kaz.
Keen to understand why Kaz pied him in the challenge, Toby approaches her for a chat.
Referring to the situation with Chloe, Kaz says: ‘You did lie to me… In bed when I said, ‘Anything extra to say?’ you were like, ‘No, no’ and then the next day you were like, ‘Oh yeah we kissed on the terrace.’ That was a lie.’
Shock: The fight broke out over the scenes in Monday’s Snog, Marry, Pie contest
Chatting away: The group were all discussing the previous day’s game
Confused: Fashion blogger Kaz, 26, is confronted by the semi-professional footballer, 22, (pictured) who demands an answer to why she chose to ‘pie’ him out of all the boys
Toby asks: ‘Is that a lie?’ to which Kaz responds: ‘It was a lie. It’s not a drama. Obviously the thing is at the end of the day you were disrespectful, a little bit.’
Toby asks: ‘Disrespectful?’ to which Kaz says: ‘You don’t think you were?’
Toby replies: ‘If I could go back, I don’t think I have any regrets.’ He says: ‘I don’t think I have any regrets because I told you how it was from the jump.’
Kaz responds: ‘You said, if you could do everything again, you’d do it exactly how you did it. I don’t respect that. But that’s just you.’
Kicking back: The lads were working things out during the episode
Answers: Keen to understand why Kaz pied him in the challenge, Toby approaches her for a chat (pictured as Kaz decides who to ‘pie’)
Eek! Faye was weighing in on the scenario in defense of her pal
She adds: ‘Listen, where you are today is none of my business. I’m happy for you and Chloe to do your thing. However, do I feel like you could have treated me way better? 100%.’
Toby says: ‘Now looking back, now from your point of view I understand. Now you said it.’
But Kaz, who walks away from the conversation, says: ‘What the f***? You just said if you could go back, you would do things the exact same way. And now you’re saying, alright, understand.’
Later, when Toby is talking to some of the boys about what’s happened, he overhears Faye dismissing his actions. The pair get into a heated chat across the garden. And later Toby is also keen to speak to Kaz’s best friend Liberty who has some advice for him.
Difficult: It sent shockwaves through the villa when Toby and Kaz broke up earlier in the season over blonde bombshell Chloe (pictured)
Elsewhere on the upcoming episode, continuing Toby’s analogy of football, the girls are keen to discuss Liberty and Jake’s bedroom shenanigans.
Faye laughs to Liberty: ‘We’ve got a ‘1-1′ haven’t we?’
Chloe in Beach Hut explains: ‘So one all is, basically doing bits, one all. You did something, I did something, we both had a very happy ending… [laughs]’
Millie responds to Liberty: ‘No you haven’t!’ while Liberty says: ‘I’m just going to sip my tea and mind my own business’ before joking: ‘There’s you guys thinking this is the first time…’
Sweet: In other scenes on Tuesday night’s episode, Faye and Teddy enjoy their first date together
Chloe adds: ‘Cheeky, cheeky ‘Jiberty’
Chloe adds: ‘Cheeky, cheeky ‘Jiberty’.’
AJ asks if anyone else has, Millie says: ‘I haven’t, yet, ha ha.’
In other scenes, Faye and Teddy enjoy their first date and the islanders enjoy a 70s themed party only to be interrupted by the news that there is another dumping just around the corner.
Love Island continues tonight at 9pm on ITV2 and ITV Hub.
Bust a move: The islanders also enjoy a 70s themed party only to be interrupted by the news that there is another dumping just around the corner
Girl time! The girls enjoyed some dedicated girl talk